Search
  • Mark Ryan

EPA Files an Interesting Brief in the Sackett case

EPA today filed its response brief in the Sackett appeal, and it's an interesting one. You will recall that EPA withdrew its administrative order against the Sacketts and then moved to dismiss the Sacketts' appeal of the case EPA had won in District Court on the validity of the order. The Ninth Cir. then surprisingly denied the motion to dismiss. (See my Blogposts from March 30, April 1, 9 and 16 and May 22 for more background).


EPA's brief renews the mootness argument that it raised in its failed motion to dismiss. Its merits argument, however, is the interesting one. Starting at page 32 of the brief, EPA argues that the Kennedy test is the law of the Circuit, and EPA met the significant nexus test in issuing the compliance order to the Sacketts. The new WOTUS rule, which went into effect on Monday, rejects the Kennedy test in favor of the plurality's RPW test. I suppose EPA will argue that it's entitled to reinterpret the CWA under Brand X, but the position it takes in this brief seems to contradict its view of the law in the N.D. Cal. case. They're clearly trying to thread a needle here, but I'm not sure they're succeeding. This brief will likely be exhibit A in some of the enviro challenges to the new rule. It'll be interesting to see how EPA deals with it.



If you would like to receive email notifications of new blogposts, go to the signup button above, leave your email, and you'll be alerted to updates.

32 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Waterkeeper Files NOI in Coal Ash Case

Waterkeeper last week served the NOI below on Ameren Corp, which is an electric utility in Missouri. The NOI alleges that Ameren is discharging without a permit wastewater from coal ash ponds into the

Two New (Oddball) CWA Cases

These two cases bring up issues one seldom sees in the case law, which makes them mildly interesting. Reading the clever arguments raised by defendants in the Earth Island case below reminded me of my

A Modest Proposal to Fix WOTUS

As I have argued numerous times in the past, Congress needs to fix the WOTUS problem. They created it by so vaguely defining “navigable waters,” and only they can permanently fix the problem (assuming

© 2016 by Ryan & Kuehler PLLC.

  • Facebook Basic Black
  • LinkedIn Basic Black
  • Twitter Basic Black