• Mark Ryan

EPA Moves to Dismiss 401 Cert. Rule Challenge

On September 14, EPA filed a motion to dismiss an enviro group challenge to the new 401 cert. rule on the grounds that the challenge is not ripe, and the rule can only be challenged under the APA in the context of a particular application of the rule. EPA also challenges standing in the case. On October 5, the EPA filed its reply brief. The latter brief is attached below. See my July 15 blogpost for a discussion of the filing of the complaint in this matter.

In my earlier blogposts, I have argued that the new rule ignores clear Supreme Court precedent, and will likely be overturned. If what EPA argues is true, then almost any APA challenge to a rulemaking would be unripe until the rule was actually applied. How is this different from the WOTUS rule? If a newly-promulgated rule is unauthorized by the underlying Act or is an arbitrary and capricious interpretation of the Act, doesn't the APA allow judicial review of a final agency action, assuming plaintiffs have standing? It will be interesting to see what the court does with this.

EPA 401 cert. opp br. 10.5.20
Download PDF • 149KB

If you would like to receive email notifications of new blogposts, go to the signup button above, leave your email, and you'll be alerted to updates.


Recent Posts

See All

A Slew of New CWA Cases

As I mentioned in my October 3 blogpost, the courts have been on a tear. Since October 3, I've blogged about 15 new cases, and today I add seven more to that number (plus a summary of the SF Baykeeper

EPA Wins an Iowa CAFO Case

An EPA ALJ today ruled in EPA's favor in a CAFO enforcement action in Armstrong, Iowa. A copy of the 108-page decision is attached below. The case was filed in 2016, and went to hearing in December 20

© 2016 by Ryan & Kuehler PLLC.

  • Facebook Basic Black
  • LinkedIn Basic Black
  • Twitter Basic Black