• Mark Ryan

New Penalty/505(a) Preemption Case

Updated: Feb 23

This case addresses issues that commonly arise in NDPES permit enforcement cases: preemption and daily max versus monthly average counting for days of violation. The holding on preemption is worth reading because it comes up often and defendants lose this one more often than not.

Lower Susquehanna Riverkeeper v. Keystone Protein Co., No. 1:19-cv-01307 (M.D. Pa. 2021) (on motion for summary judgment in case involving alleged violations of NPDES permit, held that plaintiffs had representational standing; prior state consent agreements negotiated with defendant that did not involve public notice and comment did not preclude the present lawsuit under § 505(a)(1) or § 309(g)(6)(A) because they were not brought under a law comparable to the CWA; court adopted the “rough comparability” test for determining comparability to the CWA; CWA is a strict liability statute; court granted SJ on 288 daily max violations, but deferred until the penalty phase SJ on all monthly average violations to determine whether they overlapped with the daily max violations)

51 SJ opinion
Download PDF • 139KB

If you would like to receive email notifications of new blogposts, go to the signup button above, leave your email, and you'll be alerted to updates.

38 views2 comments

Recent Posts

See All

A Special Treat

In my April 12 blogpost, I explained that I would be retiring soon, and with retirement I would be retiring the CWA Blog at the end of May. In that post, I referenced a special treat for my readers. A

Six New Cases

We have three Circuit Court cases this round, which is unusual. None are earth-shaking, but the Rio Hondo case is worth a read if TMDL/anti-backsliding/WQ permit limits are your thing. The Center for

Enviro Groups Sue the Corps Over Pipelines

A number of environmental groups have sued the Corps over NWP 12, alleging that the modifications to the NWP failed to properly analyze environmental impacts of pipelines. The NWP modifications pushed